Utley the best 2B of all time?

mofome · 05-26-08 10:45 PM

Yes or No?

SlickFazzer · 05-26-08 10:47 PM

My knowledge of 2B sucks, but how does Sandberg stack up to Utley?

Deuce · 05-26-08 10:49 PM

Robinson is better than Utley.

JRS21386 · 05-26-08 10:50 PM

Kelly Johnson

JRS21386 · 05-26-08 10:50 PM

Ok that was a joke... he's solid though... 9 game hitting streak, battin over .300

MJFtheGenius · 05-26-08 10:51 PM

no i will take Robinson Cano over him

Deuce · 05-26-08 10:51 PM

Originally Posted by MJFtheGenius

no i will take Robinson Cano over him

Jackie

flyingillini · 05-26-08 10:52 PM

not even close! Not even in the top 20 probably of all time

TexansFan · 05-26-08 10:53 PM

NO!!!

MJFtheGenius · 05-26-08 10:53 PM

Originally Posted by Deuce

Jackie

nope I mean Cano

Deuce · 05-26-08 10:54 PM

Polanco is better.

SlickFazzer · 05-26-08 10:55 PM

Lou Whitaker

MJFtheGenius · 05-26-08 10:58 PM

Originally Posted by Deuce

Polanco is better.

Polanco is better

I would take Brian Roberts over him too

donjuan · 05-26-08 11:06 PM

Career EQAs:

Utley .305
Cano .283
Polanco .269
Whitaker .290
Sandberg .284

Utley needs a few more years but he is certainly an excellent hitting 2B, much better than anyone listed bar Jackie Robinson.

robzilla · 05-26-08 11:09 PM

you atleast need a couple world series rings....

Roberto Alomar was pretty good.

Roach23 · 05-26-08 11:12 PM

yes

MJFtheGenius · 05-26-08 11:24 PM

Originally Posted by donjuan

Career EQAs:

Utley .305
Cano .283
Polanco .269
Whitaker .290
Sandberg .284

Utley needs a few more years but he is certainly an excellent hitting 2B, much better than anyone listed bar Jackie Robinson.

Cano is younger

the sky is the limit for this guy

donjuan · 05-26-08 11:35 PM

Cano is younger

the sky is the limit for this guy

That wasn't the question and that is not what was stated in your reply.

MJFtheGenius · 05-26-08 11:36 PM

Yea I said i will take Cano

if i started a team today I will take Cano because he is younger and will be better then Utley

Roach23 · 05-26-08 11:52 PM

Originally Posted by MJFtheGenius

Yea I said i will take Cano

if i started a team today I will take Cano because he is younger and will be better then Utley

you're a ****ing retard

donjuan · 05-26-08 11:56 PM

Yea I said i will take Cano

if i started a team today I will take Cano because he is younger and will be better then Utley

Again, this has nothing to do with the question posed and is certainly debatable given how much better Utley is than Cano.

element1286 · 05-26-08 11:56 PM

How about Joe Morgan.

MJFtheGenius · 05-26-08 11:57 PM

everyone tells me that Roach when I say this

but the sky is the limit for Cano

Utley on great run right now but before this season this was a very valid arguement I am not going to let a span of 50 games change my mind

element1286 · 05-26-08 11:57 PM

Originally Posted by MJFtheGenius

everyone tells me that Roach when I say this

but the sky is the limit for Cano

Utley on great run right now but before this season this was a very valid arguement I am not going to let a span of 50 games change my mind

Utley is a much better player than Cano. Homerism at it's finest.

donjuan · 05-26-08 11:58 PM

Utley on great run right now but before this season this was a very valid arguement I am not going to let a span of 50 games change my mind

How about 132 games last year where he had an EQA of .331 and an OBP of .410?

MJFtheGenius · 05-26-08 11:59 PM

Originally Posted by donjuan

Again, this has nothing to do with the question posed and is certainly debatable given how much better Utley is than Cano.

alright your right it is not answering the first question

but I can't see how you justify Utley as the greatest hitting 2nd baseman of all time right now

he has not done it for a long enough time

element1286 · 05-27-08 12:00 AM

Originally Posted by MJFtheGenius

alright your right it is not answering the first question

but I can't see how you justify Utley as the greatest hitting 2nd baseman of all time right now

he has not done it for a long enough time

You're right Joe Morgan is the greatest hitting second basemen of all time.

MJFtheGenius · 05-27-08 12:01 AM

I agree with morgan over Utley

donjuan · 05-27-08 12:01 AM

alright your right it is not answering the first question

but I can't see how you justify Utley as the greatest hitting 2nd baseman of all time right now

he has not done it for a long enough time

Can you read?

Utley needs a few more years but he is certainly an excellent hitting 2B, much better than anyone listed bar Jackie Robinson.

MJFtheGenius · 05-27-08 12:02 AM

Originally Posted by element1286

Utley is a much better player than Cano. Homerism at it's finest.

Cano will shape up

Right now alot of pitchers are throwing him inside

he is not handling it too well right now

I have faith in him

MJFtheGenius · 05-27-08 12:03 AM

Originally Posted by donjuan

Can you read?

Yes

are you an asshole?

donjuan · 05-27-08 12:04 AM

Yes

are you an asshole?

1. Apparently not.
2. Sometimes.

2Pac · 05-27-08 12:05 AM

No one has mentioned Rogers Hornsby?

Guy hit 300 HR and had a career BA of .360

2Pac · 05-27-08 12:07 AM

Ryan Sandberg was a fukkmin clown and didn't deserve HOF.

Best of all time?
Hornsby
Morgan
Collins
LaJoie
Mazeroski

donjuan · 05-27-08 12:12 AM

Good list but how did Maz get on there? The guy was a terrible hitter, although a very good fielder.

Poster's Sportsbook Poll: 2011View Poll Results
# 1 5Dimes	450 total points	5Dimes Review
# 2 Pinnacle	408 total points	Pinnacle Review
# 3 Heritage	227 total points	Heritage Review
# 4 Bookmaker	138 total points	Bookmaker Review
# 5 BetIslands	129 total points	BetIslands Review

SBR Top-Rated SportsbooksRecommended List
Pinnacle Sports	SBR Rating A+	Pinnacle Sports Review
5Dimes	SBR Rating A+	5Dimes Review
BookMaker	SBR Rating A+	BookMaker Review
Legends	SBR Rating A+	Legends Review
Bodog	SBR Rating A	Bodog Review

Thread Tools

Utley the best 2B of all time?

May Contests

Wednesday the 30th