Other than Vanderbilt's hot start from three-point range, the biggest factor in the game were the referees who seemed intent on controlling the proceedings.
All told the game saw both teams whistled for 53 fouls and both sides had their share of gripes. Tennessee was called for 27, Vanderbilt for 26.
It made the game a long, hard slog and had a very clear impact on the way things played out starting from the outset.
Tennessee was whistled for nine fouls in just over 12 minutes of play with the most severe blow coming when Wayne Chism went to the bench with his third foul of the game with 7:40 still left in the first half.
The foul trouble in the post extended well beyond Chism. Duke Crews and Brian Williams both picked up two fouls in the first 10 minutes, prompting Ryan Childress to get on the court for some rare first half action.
Vanderbilt had its own issues, chief among them A.J. Ogilvy joining Chism on the bench after picking up his third at the 6:28 mark.
"I think the foul trouble, with those early fouls, he and Ogilvy kind of cancelled each other out. It turned into a different kind of a game," Pearl said. "There were a lot of fouls, it was hard to get any kind of a rhythm. We couldn't get the tempo up."
And as bad as the first half was in regard to the whistles, the second half appeared to be even worse. Tennessee was on the line shooting 1-and-1 with only 3:57 gone by in the second half and by the nine-minute mark of the second half both teams were in the double bonus.
No matter who you were rooting for, the fouls were excessive, affected the flow of the game and were an example the referees ruling with too strong a hand.
No Excuses
Everyone knew before Tennessee left for Memphis last Friday that going 2-0 on the just completed road trip would be a quite a feat. The loss tonight was hardly the 'upset' some will make it out to be considering both the environment and the opponent.
No one on the Tennessee team was interested in using Saturday's tank-draining effort at Memphis as an excuse for losing at Vandy though.
Pearl saw a much simpler explanation for the loss; namely two players who showed up and didn't get a lot of help.
"We were fine, we were absolutely fine. We had no problem as far as our rest or our preparation. It wasn't a factor," Pearl said emphatically. "Tyler Smith played with such passion and energy, and Chris Lofton played well for us. We play best when everyone contributes and tonight we just didn't get a lot of contributions from a lot of guys we normally do."
But What Is A Problem Is This…
While Pearl didn't have any interest in using physical or mental fatigue as an excuse, he had no problem identifying the area of his team that gave him the most concern leaving Memorial Gymnasium.
"We've got to get better point guard play. I can tell you that. It's difficult from the bench to have to set the table to much. Those guys have got to do a better job of leading the team," Pearl said, mincing few words.
"If I knew (what the problem was) I'd fix it."
Starter Ramar Smith finished the night with eight points, three assist and two turnovers while going just 2-of-5 from the free throw line.
Jordan Howell had another in what has been a string of troubling performances, scoring zero points on 0-of-2 shooting and failing to register a rebound or an assist in the game.
Howell's cold shooting dates back to the Florida game. In the last six games, the senior is 2-of-19 from three-point range.
Eyes on the Prize
After the game the Vols' players were far more upset about the hit they're going to take in the SEC standings as opposed to any fall out in the rankings as a result of the Vandy loss.
Tennessee still controls its own destiny in the SEC, and can clinch an outright title with three more wins, but the Vols weren't pleased with letting this one slip away.
"The whole No. 1 thing was good for the program and it made our school look good but that was never our main focus," Duke Crews said of the situation. "Our main focus has always been to win the SEC championship, so win or lose going into the Memphis game, this one was a bigger game for us. We haven't done it in 41 years so this was the bigger game the whole time."
Techs Are Flying
In addition to calling every touch foul available to them the refs also managed to squeeze off three technical fouls in the game. Kevin Stallings caught one of them from the Vandy bench, Bruce Pearl caught one on his end, and JaJuan Smith was 'Teed' up as well in the second half.
Part of Pearl's 'blow-up' appeared calculated, but the head coach said it was fueled by what he felt was a lack of respect for his team.
"I felt like…Vanderbilt shot more free throws than we did when they came to Thompson-Boling, in a 20-point loss. We're a good basketball team," Pearl said of what he was thinking at the time. "We've beaten Xavier, Mississippi State and Memphis on the road. We've beaten three top-25 teams on the road…I was obviously unhappy."
For his part, Smith said he was stunned when he drew his technical.
"I asked the ref what the call was and he T'd me up. I thought a captain a could do that," Smith said of the offense.
Weathering the Storm
In the Memphis game the Vols watched the opponent start out 7-of-11 from three point range. Tonight Vandy's Shan Foster threatened to match that kind of effort on his own. The senior wing was 4-of-5 from deep in the first half, hit three in a row at one point, and finished 6-of-9 from downtown on his way to a game-high 32.
His early theatrics helped put Tennessee in a 23-9 hole that the Vols were fortunate to dig out of.
"Foster's a great player, great shooter. He's a guy that you have to try and make beat you from two. We didn't do that tonight," Pearl said.
Déjà vu
Not much else about the game was similar but the start to this one played out like the first meeting in Knoxville.
Vanderbilt obviously wanted to go inside tonight, and A.J. Ogilvy obviously wanted to even the score against Wayne Chism after that first match-up went heavily in Chism's favor.
But that early focus got nowhere when Chism stuffed Ogilvy's first shot on the first possession of the game, in nearly mirror image play of what happened to start the game in Knoxville.
Neither player was much of a factor in the game however.
Chism finished with just four points and three rebounds in 23 minutes. Ogilvy matched him with four points and three rebounds in only 12 minutes on the floor.