Try these sites for talking points regarding US gambling laws:
http://www.gamblingandthelaw.com/
http://www.gambling-law-us.com/
Lots of stuff there, if you have time to go through it all....
I am not sure what the theme of you discussion is, but basically my problem with the whole thing as a US citizen is that our government has determined through the passing of the UIGEA that Americans of legal age cannot participate in something that citizens around the world are allowed to enjoy. Great Britain has established legal, regulated and taxed on-line betting for a number of years, meanwhile the US is allowing millions of taxable dollars to flow offshore.
The UIGEA is non-enforcable, according to many experts, and the WTO has taken action against the US Govt through fines and potential legal action. All the UIGEA has done is make it more difficult for US accounts to deposit and withdraw funds.
It is unlikely the US Govt would ever allow legalized on-line gambling regardless of the taxable benefits of a Vegas centered on-line gambling center due to the lobbying efforts of the Sports Leagues (NFL, NBA, MLB...) who fear undue influences on their respective sports. You could argue that FIFA and the English premier league continues to flourish in the midst of legalized on-line gambling, but no politician would ever back a thing.
Meanwhile, many states continue to use lotteries, horse racing, and slots to fund their budgets.
On-line poker has made some headway into establishing legalized on-line gambling; however, their proposals (namely the Frank proposal) would likely eliminate sports betting through "opt-out" clauses to appease the sports leagues. States would also have the option to opt-out of a federal on-line gambling law - thus leaving the US sports bettor to stay with their offshore accounts.
Now for the crazy talk.......................
If a legal vegas on-line book was available, I would drop my offshore account immediately.
Vegas would run their operations as they do now, through the Vig, and the US Govt would skim the taxes off that. Otherwise the US govt would require the Vegas on-line books to pay licensing and regulatory fees.....We would just be subjected to the juice we pay now, and Vegas would likely do what they have to do to push the flow of money their way (and could even lower the juice because they may have the resources and finances to do so to compete against the other on-line books out there.)
All Vegas would do is launch on-line operations (with software they already have and tested) and likely do a better job that 95% of the bozo's that operate offshore right now with better lines and real customer service departments. Attracting the international community to put their money into properly run US on-line Vegas books could be a boon to this country, but the short sightedness of the US Govt will continue to stop this. Hell the US govt has no problems being the number one arms dealer in the world, why not expand into the legal gambling sector as well?
We are talking potential billions - Joe Schmoe opening a $150 on-line account with Ceasars to place a few dollars on the Cowboys in the Super Bowl....Progressive NFL handicapping contests under Hilton that is open nationwide with a $50 entry....nationwide NFL suicide pools run by Ballys....$10 entries into MLB fantasy leagues under Harrah's.... This is why the sports leagues would have an aneurysm if someone in congress even suggests a proposal for legalized on-line gambling in the USA.
Poker is something people watch and play all the time and that alone would generate millions of taxable dollars into the USA. Since the Absolute Poker scam, the on-line poker industry would only benefit from regulated and licensed on-line poker in the US.
I am sure a lot of the off-shore gaming community would shake at the potential of competing against well reputable US Vegas on-line book agencies that would do things properly (or appear to do so) rather than risk losing their license. I can only think of the possible bonus potential alone (people get free trips and rooms for putting a few hundred in those slot machines alone!)
I would prefer that my money be in a safer place than the off-shore book I have right now - An offshore book that has no real regulatory agency or licensing requirements on how they ruin things, and could run with my account dollars if they just decided to take it with no real potential legal actions against them.
I would prefer a percentage of my Vig money to be used to help the US through the taxes generated through a reputable and competitive on-line Vegas book and poker site as well, instead of all of it just going towards Calvin Ayers' next lowbrow scheme.
The US Govt is fooling itself if it thinks it can regulate internet content and international polices regarding internet usage. Meanwhile, the US is falling behind the rest of the world regarding on-line gambling opportunities and losing millions upon millions of taxable dollars to the rest of the world. The USA produces NFL, MLB, NCAA and NBA games for the rest of the world to enjoy and gamble upon, and the USA should grab those dollars flowing out to offshore agencies and try to reel in those dollars for our own benefit as well.
GL.