[MartinBlank]

JJ threw out Warner as a top-10 QB of all-time.

Do you agree?

Which QBs make your list?

My list. In no particular order.

1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Peyton Manning
4. Aikman
5. Marino
6. Unitas
7. Favre
8. Elway
9. Bradshaw
10. Staubach

Which of those QBs would Warner replace?

Not a one in my books.

Honorable mention would go to:

Namath
Kelly
Starr
Stabler

[Unicorn7]

Wheres Fouts?

[MartinBlank]

Good one Uni.

I would place Fouts among my honorable mention lists.

Every one of my top-10 with the exception of Marino won a Championship. Marino gets a pass because he may have been the best pure passer of all-time.

[roasthawg]

1. Montana
2. Manning
3. Marino
4. Young
5. Brady
6. Favre
7. Elway
8. Warner
9. Aikman
10. Kelly

I've only been watching football since the 80's so I didn't back before that.

[Grux]

What about Otto Graham and Steve Young?
OTTO GRAHAM (Cleveland 1946-55)
Best NFL season (1953): 167 for 258 (64.7%), 2,722 yards, 10.6 YPA, 11 TD, 9 INT, 99.7 passer rating
Career (includes AAFC career): 1,464 for 2,626 (55.8%), 23,584 yards, 9.0 YPA, 174 TD, 135 INT, 86.6 passer rating
Championships: AAFC 1946-49; NFL 1950, 1954, 1955
Overview: Otto Graham was Tom Brady before Tom Brady, putting up gaudy numbers for his time while winning games and championships at an unprecedented rate. He led the Browns to a championship in all four years of the AAFC’s existence (1946-49). But he and the Browns proved they belonged in the big leagues by capturing the NFL title in their first year in the league.

In fact, they’d go on to set a record that still stands, appearing in six straight NFL championship games from 1950 to 1955, winning three of them. Bottom line: Graham played in a pro football championship game every single season of his 10-year career, winning seven of them in two different leagues.

He also set passing marks that stood for decades. His 86.6 passer rating, for example, is the top mark of the pre-Live Ball Era. And his career 9.0 YPA is No. 1 by a sizable margin.

So why, then, isn’t Graham higher on the list?

His four years in the AAFC make for some awkward comparisons. There’s every reason to believe the Browns would have been a dominant NFL team over those four years, but little reason to believe they would have won four straight championships. Graham’s numbers also declined pretty noticeably when he went to the NFL, from simply unbelievable to merely spectacular. His career 9.0 YPA average, for example, drops to 8.63 if we look only at his NFL numbers. Of course, that 8.63 YPA mark is the best in NFL history, too.

The full measure of Graham’s impact is this: the organization has never recovered from his departure at the end of the 1955 season. Sure, they remained competitive through the Jim Brown years (1957-65), winning a championship in 1964.

But that’s the only championship the organization won since Graham last took a snap for the Browns.

[MartinBlank]

Interesting Roast.

Good list. But I still couldn't put Warner ahead of a 4-time Super Bowl winner like Bradshaw, or a QB like Staubach.

Staubach was a lot of fun to watch.

And nice Steve Young selection. He could very well be in anyone's top 10.

[JohnGalt2341]

I'm too lazy and buzzed to name 10 but I'll take P. Manning over anyone.

[roasthawg]

Interesting Roast.

Good list. But I still couldn't put Warner ahead of a 4-time Super Bowl winner like Bradshaw, or a QB like Staubach.

Staubach was a lot of fun to watch.

And nice Steve Young selection. He could very well be in anyone's top 10.

Yeah, like I said I only watched football from the mid-80's on... guys like Bradshaw and Unitas don't make my list simply cause I never saw them. Montana was hands down the best qb I've ever seen... the best ever at throwing on the move. His accuracy was pin point no matter which direction his feet were taking him... amazing.

[Rollins08]

Favre us overrated on almost all polls. If you had to win one game you would choose almost all those other guys over him.

1. Manning (needs another super bowl)
2. Montana
3. Unitas
4. Brady
5. Marino
6. Tarkenton
7. Graham
8. Bradshaw
9. Elway
10. Favre

[PAULYPOKER]

1.Farve because his records are safe for lets see FOREVER!!! and he'll probably get another Superbowl this year

2.Montana no reason needed

3.Elway all time greatest comeback king with inhuman strength body&arm

4.Brady part of a dynasty belichick deserves half the credit

5.Manning could have been first if he was on a better managed team

6.Marino could have been higher if he had a rush attack to go with his passing

7.Young six TDs in Superbowl a record that will probably stand forever

8.Kelly All-time greatest captain of the 2:00 minute offense

9.Moon could have been higher if he played entire career in the NFL

10.Bradshaw 4 Superbowls 2 mvps. other than that mediocre

11.Roethlisberger soon to climb this list dramatically cause he is just getting started mark my words he will have 5 Superbowls under his belt by the time he retires 2 down 3 to go

[PAULYPOKER]

I don't see Ryan Leaf

It's my list nut job and I can have Jake Delhomme on it if I wish

[MartinBlank]

I think you have to have one of the Cowboy QBs on it-----either Aikman or Staubach.

[Sam Odom]

How large (top 100) of a list must some of you have to list a Black QB ?

Yeah , I saw Moon but

[mebaran]

I could tell you top 3 for me:

1. ABSOLUTELY has to be Favre. This guy's got something like 70,000 passing yards. That's absolutely amazing.
2. Dan Marino for me. Someone already stated how great of a pure passer he was. He is the epitome of what you want in a QB.
3. Manning because of his total understanding of the game and his superior management. The guy is a robot.

[mebaran]

How large (top 100) of a list must some of you have to list a Black QB ?

Yeah , I saw Moon but

McNabb prob in top 25. He's got over 200 TDs right?

[PAULYPOKER]

I could tell you top 3 for me: 1. ABSOLUTELY has to be Favre. This guy's got something like 70,000 passing yards. That's absolutely amazing. 2. Dan Marino for me. Someone already stated how great of a pure passer he was. He is the epitome of what you want in a QB. 3. Manning because of his total understanding of the game and his superior management. The guy is a robot.

ALL TIME QUARTERBACK LEADERS

Passing Yardage Leaders ALLTIME
RanK PLAYER ----YDS
1 BRETT FAVRE 69,013
2 Dan Marino 61,361
3 John Elway 51,475
4 PEYTON MANNING 50,033

Touchdown Pass Leaders ALLTIME
RanK--PLAYER-----TD
1 BRETT FAVRE 493
2 Dan Marino 420
3 PEYTON MANNING 366
4 Fran Tarkenton 342
5 John Elway 300

Pass Completion Leaders ALLTIME
Rank-- Name completions
1 BRETT FAVRE 6,058
2 Dan Marino 4,967
3 PEYTON MANNING 4,218
4 John Elway 4,123
5 Warren Moon 3,988

I would say Brett's records will be safe lets see how can I put this FOREVER!!!

[smitch124]

ALL TIME QUARTERBACK LEADERS

Passing Yardage Leaders ALLTIME
RanK PLAYER ----YDS
1 BRETT FAVRE 69,013
2 Dan Marino 61,361
3 John Elway 51,475
4 PEYTON MANNING 50,033

Touchdown Pass Leaders ALLTIME
RanK--PLAYER-----TD
1 BRETT FAVRE 493
2 Dan Marino 420
3 PEYTON MANNING 366
4 Fran Tarkenton 342
5 John Elway 300

Pass Completion Leaders ALLTIME
Rank-- Name completions
1 BRETT FAVRE 6,058
2 Dan Marino 4,967
3 PEYTON MANNING 4,218
4 John Elway 4,123
5 Warren Moon 3,988

I would say Brett's records will be safe lets see how can I put this FOREVER!!!

How can you say that? Manning will pass him in everything.

[PAULYPOKER]

All time painkilling consuming machine at number one: Brett.... FAVRE!

Actually he is the only one with balls enough to admit it publicly but he quit the habit over a decade ago and if you are naive to believe anyone else never had this problem I feel sorry for you

[PAULYPOKER]

How can you say that? Manning will pass him in everything.

Serious question what kind of crack are you smoking???

[Wayne]

You forgot one: Performance under fire. Joe Montana

[PAULYPOKER]

Funny you should ask, I was wondering the same thing of you

You a funny guy

[Wayne]

1. Joe Montana
2. Peyton Manning
3. Johnny Unitas
4. Dan Marino
5. Tom Brady
6. John Elway
7. Dan Fouts
8. Roger Staubach
9. Terry Bradshaw
10. Brett Favre

[odusmykal]

I don't see Ryan Leaf

Guy once had a game with 4 yards & 2 INTs.. Haven't thought about him in a while.. Wonder where he is now?. Possibly rehab somewhere..

[Wheell]

10. Brett Farve
9. Roger Staubach
8. Tom Brady
7. Johnny Unitas
6. Peyton Manning
5. Steve Young
4. Otto Graham
3. Bart Starr
2. Sammy Baugh
1. Joe Montana

Honorable mentions:

Dan Marino
Sonny Jurgensen
Terry Bradshaw

[lakerboy]

1- Montana
2- Manning
3-Unitas
4-Tarkenton
5-Marino
6-Elway
7-Favre
8-Young
9-Staubach
10-luckman

[SBR_John]

1. Montana
2. Staubach
3. Favre
4. Young
5. Aikman
6. Kelly
7. Fouts
8. Peyton Manning
9. Elway
10. Tarkenton

[Eatminus]

1. Manning
2. Favre
3. Elway
4. Marino
5. Montana