[alukk]

top 3: peyton, brady and brees

[ATB515]

not really. Morons like to think that way (Giants fans for the most part), but that's not the case. Dan Marino or Trent Dilfer? Dan Fouts or Eli Manning? Jim Kelly or Jeff Hostetler? Fran Tarkenton or Doug Williams?

for manning to only make 1 sb is a joke. hes a big-stage choker if you ask me....trent dilfer has as many rings, qbs judged by how many sbs you win....so i say jim plunkett is better than manning. go eat some oreos peyton.

[armyoflovers]

[quote=ATB515;2082198]not really. Morons like to think that way (Giants fans for the most part), but that's not the case. Dan Marino or Trent Dilfer? Dan Fouts or Eli Manning? Jim Kelly or Jeff Hostetler? Fran Tarkenton or Doug Williams?



Wrong! When I think of Marino, I think never won the SB....when I think of Dilfer or Mark Rypien I think of fearless leaders who lead his men into the trenches and rose victorious....men like marino were shallow soldiers not venerable veterans

[james4512]

peyton is hands down the best qb in the league. Brady has the best coach plus they were cheating its really hard to say how much that could have benefited from it in their super bowl wins. Rothlisburger? are you kiding me? Hes a bum always has a good running game above average recievers and the best defense in the game. Peyton made marvin harrison and reggie wayne with his amazing throws and his timing + the way he moves in the pocket and avoids defenders is unreal, not to mention he has always had a horrible defense and a below average special teams. Best QB since Marino/Elway with no doubt about it